Employer health benefits are in crisis — here’s how payers are strategizing

Advertisement

From work requirements for the expansion population to the ending of enhanced premium tax credits, Medicaid and the ACA have been dominating headlines. But those groups alone do not tell the full story of healthcare access and cost.

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, in 2025, 53.5% of the civilian, noninstitutionalized population had employment-based health insurance, followed by 20.1% in Medicare, 17.1% in Medicaid, 10.5% in directly purchased coverage, and smaller shares in military- or veteran-related coverage. Because some people held more than one type of coverage during the year, the shares total more than 100%. The uninsured rate was 7.9%.

Employers and their workers have been facing immense cost pressures leading up to 2027. Aon projected U.S. employer healthcare costs would rise 9.5% in 2027, with average costs per employee surpassing $19,000. Marsh estimated the total health benefit cost per employee would increase 8.2% on average in 2027, even after considering planned cost-reduction steps. A Harvard University T.H. Chan School of Public Health article cited inflation, high-cost medications and hospital consolidation as key factors. Utilization has been another component.

On average, covered employees contributed $7,471 toward their family coverage in 2026, up 9% from 2025, according to KFF. This outpaced the growth of overall family premiums (5%), as well as the increase in workers’ wages (3.7%).

Some employers — ranging from Disney to Starbucks to healthcare companies themselves — have been cutting back as they try to manage steeper costs. GLP-1 coverage for weight loss has been one notable area for pullback.

To sum up: More than half of the population could be facing some big changes with their employer-sponsored insurance, resulting in higher costs or fewer benefits — or both.

As employers grapple with these costs, some health insurers have been surfacing their own solutions. Here are some of commercial insurers’ biggest bets in the employer space right now.

Alternative funding models

Alternatives to fully insured models have been gaining traction in recent years. Traditional fully insured models involve employers paying insurers to take on risk, whereas, with self-funding, employers pay claims directly and hire insurers to manage backend administration.

Self-funding has remained steadily popular among large employers, holding at roughly 80% of their covered workers between 2015 and 2025. The share of covered workers at small firms — with 10 to 199 employees — in level-funded coverage, a self-funded hybrid that includes stop-loss coverage, grew from 6% in 2018 to 37% in 2025, per KFF. In 2018, 19% of covered workers at small firms had either level- or self-funded coverage, eventually reaching 51% in 2025.

Insurers are leaning in. For example, Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey is joining the third-party administrator market with HealthEZ, which the insurer purchased in 2025. Solutions are available with Jan. 1 effective dates. 

In 2025, Elevance Health announced plans to acquire stop-loss insurer Granular Insurance, signaling a commercial push. The transaction has since closed. Separately, Elevance’s commercial health benefits president, Morgan Kendrick, previously told Becker’s that employers are increasingly turning to alternative models, such as multiple employer welfare arrangements. This model involves risk-pooling across employers.

CHOICE

Custom health option and individual care expense arrangements, formerly known as individual coverage health reimbursement arrangements, have gained renewed attention amid the recent rebrand. Under CHOICE arrangements, employers provide their workers with fixed, tax-free contributions to purchase individual health insurance.

Between 2020 and 2025, adoption has skyrocketed, growing more than 1,000%, according to an HRA Council report. While small employers have historically made up much of the market, adoption among employers with more than 50 employees has been promising, up 34% from 2024 to 2025. The council estimated more than 500,000 covered lives at the start of 2026.

Centene and Oscar Health are among the most invested payer players in the space right now. Centene is expanding where it offers plans designed for CHOICE, bringing the options to four more states in 2027. Oscar had been collaborating on ICHRAx, a data exchange for carriers and administrators, as well. To cement their commitment to CHOICE, both companies are increasingly rolling out these arrangements to their own employees. 

New plan designs and products

Health insurers have not just been thinking about how to administer and fund plans but also how to structure them. Even as employers shape the benefits they cover, health plans have also been considering the scope of their networks. 

Exclusive provider organizations, or EPOs, are one avenue that Independence Blue Cross, Capital Blue Cross and Harvard Pilgrim Health Care have been exploring. These are closed-network plans that generally do not require primary care provider referrals to see specialists. EPO premiums have been lower than PPO premiums, health plan leaders confirmed to Becker’s.

Mass General Brigham Health Plan is launching a Value HMO product for large employers, built on a high-value provider network rather than a broader one. The plan will be accessible to large employers based in eight Massachusetts counties and employees who live in those counties.

Commercial insurers’ product rollouts signal a bet on how employers facing steep cost increases could trade some provider breadth for more affordable coverage.

Advertisement

Next Up in Employer-sponsored

Advertisement