The cities with the most, least competitive Medicare Advantage markets

Advertisement

UnitedHealth Group holds 96% of the Medicare Advantage market in Casper, Wyo., making it the least competitive MA market in the country, according to the AMA’s annual health insurance market competition report.

The report examined 2025 data from 385 metro areas in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, finding that one insurer held at least half the MA market in 25% of metro areas, while 97% of markets were classified as “highly concentrated” under federal merger guidelines.

UnitedHealth was the top insurer in six of the 10 least competitive MA markets and held the largest national MA market share at 30%, followed by Humana at 17% and Aetna at 12%. On the other end, Ohio dominated the most competitive MA rankings, with four of the 10 most competitive metros. 

The 10 least competitive Medicare Advantage markets:

  1. Casper, Wyo.
    UnitedHealth: 96%

  2. Cheyenne, Wyo.
    UnitedHealth: 91%

  3. Eagle Pass, Texas
    UnitedHealth: 89%

  4. St. Joseph, Mo.
    UnitedHealth: 84%

  5. Wichita Falls, Texas
    UnitedHealth: 83%

  6. Vallejo, Calif.
    Kaiser Permanente: 83%

  7. Abilene, Texas
    UnitedHealth: 81%

  8. Bend, Ore.
    PacificSource: 80%

  9. Napa, Calif.
    Kaiser Permanente: 79%

  10. Dubuque, Iowa
    Medical Associates: 77%

The 10 most competitive Medicare Advantage markets:

  1. Worcester, Mass.
    BCBS Massachusetts: 22%

  2. Grand Forks, N.D.
    Medica: 23%

  3. Canton-Massillon, Ohio
    UnitedHealth: 24%

  4. Springfield, Ohio
    Humana: 25%

  5. Baltimore-Columbia-Towson, Md.
    Aetna: 25%

  6. Gadsden, Ala.
    UnitedHealth: 25%

  7. Lima, Ohio
    Elevance Health: 25%

  8. New York-Newark-Jersey City, N.Y.
    UnitedHealth: 26%

  9. Wheeling, W.Va.
    Humana: 26%

  10. Sandusky, Ohio
    UnitedHealth: 26%
Advertisement

Next Up in Rankings & Ratings

Advertisement