The cities with the most, least competitive commercial insurance markets

Advertisement

Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama controls 90% of the commercial insurance market in Montgomery, making it the least competitive metro area in the country, according to the AMA’s annual health insurance market competition report.

The report examined combined PPO, HMO, POS and exchange enrollment as of Jan. 1, 2025 in 385 metro areas across all 50 states and the District of Columbia. One insurer held at least half the commercial market in 47% of metro areas, while 95% of metro-level commercial markets were classified as “highly concentrated” under federal merger guidelines.

Alabama dominates the least competitive end of the rankings, with five of the 10 most concentrated metros, while BCBS plans were the top insurer in all 10 areas.

The 10 least competitive commercial insurance markets:

  1. Montgomery, Ala.
    BCBS Alabama: 90%

  2. Tuscaloosa, Ala.
    BCBS Alabama: 85%

  3. Anniston-Oxford, Ala.
    BCBS Alabama: 85%

  4. Lexington-Fayette, Ky.
    Elevance Health: 83%

  5. Gadsden, Ala.
    BCBS Alabama: 80%

  6. Rochester, N.Y.
    Excellus BCBS: 80%

  7. Wichita Falls, Texas
    BCBS Texas: 79%

  8. Elizabethtown, Ky.
    Elevance Health: 79%

  9. Bay City, Mich.
    BCBS Michigan: 79%

  10. Dothan, Ala.
    BCBS Alabama: 78%

The 10 most competitive commercial insurance markets:

  1. Providence-Warwick, R.I.
    UnitedHealth Group: 21%

  2. Orlando-Kissimmee-Sanford, Fla.
    Florida Blue: 21%

  3. Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, D.C.
    CareFirst BCBS: 22%

  4. Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue, Wash.
    Premera Blue Cross: 22%

  5. Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach, Fla.
    Florida Blue: 24%

  6. Twin Falls, Idaho
    Regence BlueShield: 24%

  7. Lakeland-Winter Haven, Fla.
    Florida Blue: 24%

  8. Grants Pass, Ore.
    Regence BCBS: 24%

  9. Glens Falls, N.Y.
    Elevance Health: 24%

  10. Mount Vernon-Anacortes, Wash.
    Regence BlueShield: 24%
Advertisement

Next Up in Rankings & Ratings

Advertisement