Only 1 in 10 payers ready for electronic prior authorization in 2027: Survey

Advertisement

Only 10% of health insurers say they have fully built electronic prior authorization systems required to be in place by CMS starting next year, according to a new survey from the Workgroup for Electronic Data Interchange.

The HHS advisory group surveyed 174 payers, providers, clearinghouses and health IT vendors in September and October for its fourth readiness assessment of CMS’s 2024 Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule, which requires Medicare Advantage, managed Medicaid, and ACA marketplace insurers to stand up four FHIR-based APIs by Jan. 1.

Some provisions of the rule already took effect earlier this year, including a requirement for payers to issue standard prior auth decisions within seven calendar days and expedited decisions within 72 hours, along with providing specific reasons for denials and publicly reporting their metrics around the process.

Eight survey notes:

1. Twenty percent of payers report zero progress or are unsure of their status on the prior auth API. Another 37% are at the halfway mark, 25% are three-quarters done, and 10% say they have finished. In the early 2025 survey, half of payers said they had not started.

2. The payer-to-payer API, which will allow insurers to exchange patient data when a member switches plans, is even further behind with just 5% of payers reporting full completion. The provider access API is at 10%, while the patient access API, which builds on an existing requirement from 2020, is furthest along at 22%.

3. In 2025, payers most often cited internal strategy and digitizing their own prior authorization policies as the largest challenges to implementation. By this past October, the top challenge was third party vendors struggling to connect with different systems, followed by meeting compliance timelines and coordinating with trading partners.

4. Fifty-two percent of payers say it is somewhat to very likely they will offer prior authorization APIs through an online portal rather than a direct system-to-system connection.

5. Although payers were required to begin publicly reporting prior auth metrics earlier this year, only 70% of respondents in the October survey said they were fully ready for that obligation, up from 35% in February. Thirty percent said they are still not in full compliance with the current requirement.

6. Though the API mandate only applies to payers, half of providers in the survey said it is somewhat to very likely they will be ready to meet those provisions by 2027, down from 69% in WEDI’s first survey in early 2025. Only 36% said they are somewhat to very likely to implement the provider access API, down from 72% during the same period. At the same time, 71% of providers say it is very or extremely important that the payers they contract with support the prior auth API.

7. Ninety percent of clearinghouses now plan to conduct API exchanges on behalf of provider customers, up from 70% in February. Sixty percent plan to do so for payer customers, unchanged from the prior survey in February. Among vendors, 85% say they will help payers or providers comply with the API requirements.

8. Sixty-two percent of respondents across all categories support staggering the rollout of the three prior auth API components rather than launching them simultaneously, up from 53% in February. Of those who favor staggering, 34% prefer starting with coverage requirements discovery, then document templates and rules, then prior authorization support.

Advertisement

Next Up in Payer

Advertisement