The ratings were released Sept. 16 and are based on 2023 data from MA plans that reported HEDIS and CAHPS results to the NCQA. NCQA Accreditation status was also factored in. Plans were rated on a zero- to five-star scale, with five being the highest rating. Two MA plans received 5-stars this year, and 25 received 4.5 stars.
MA plans that received a five-star rating:
- Kaiser Colorado – HMO
- Froedtert ThedaCare Health’s Network Health (Wisconsin) – PPO
MA plans that received a 4.5-star rating:
- Aetna (Maine) – HMO/POS
- Allina Health|Aetna (Minnesota) – PPO
- BCBS Michigan – HMO/POS
- Capital District Physicians’ Health Plan (New York) – HMO
- Capital District Physicians’ Health Plan (New York) – PPO
- Capital Health Plan (Florida) – HMO
- UnitedHealth’s Care Improvement Plus South Central (New York) – PPO
- Geisinger Health Plan (Pennsylvania) – HMO
- Geisinger Health Plan (Pennsylvania) – PPO
- Kaiser Southern California – HMO
- Kaiser Northern California – HMO
- Kaiser Georgia – HMO
- Kaiser Washington – HMO
- Kaiser Mid-Atlantic (Washington, D.C.; Maryland; Virginia) – HMO
- Kaiser Northwest (Oregon, Washington) – HMO
- Kaiser Hawaii – HMO
- Medical Associates Health Plan (Wisconsin) – HMO
- Medical Associates Health Plan (Illinois, Iowa) – HMO
- Corewell’s Priority Health (Michigan) – HMO/POS
- Corewell’s Priority Health (Michigan) – PPO
- Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Oregon – HMO
- Security Health Plan of Wisconsin – HMO/POS
- UCare (Minnesota, Wisconsin) – PPO
- UPMC (Pennsylvania) – PPO
- UPMC (Ohio, Pennsylvania) – HMO
