CMS gave 31 Medicare Advantage five-star ratings for 2024, the highest rating for quality and member satisfaction awarded by the agency.
Fewer plans received a five-star rating for 2024 than for 2023. According to CMS documents published Oct. 13, 57 plans received the top rating for 2023.
The average star rating across all Medicare Advantage plans for the 2024 contract year is 4.04, down from 4.14 in 2023.
Here are the 31 contracts that received top ratings from CMS for 2024, along with their total enrollment:
Aultman Health Foundation
- PrimeTime Health Plan
Enrollment: 14,078
Devoted Health
- Devoted Health Plan of Ohio
Enrollment: 22,137
- Devoted Health Plan of Florida
Enrollment: 35,402
Elevance Health
- Simply Healthcare Plans
Enrollment: 60,723
- Optimum HealthCare
Enrollment: 59,431
Highmark Health
- Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield
Enrollment: 58,410
Humana
- Humana Health Plan of Ohio
Enrollment: 10,217
- Humana Medical Plan
Enrollment: 602,593
- Cariten Health Plan
Enrollment: 166,542
- Emphesys Insurance Co.
Enrollment: 10,662
Independent Health
- Independent Health Benefits Corp.
Enrollment: 4,943
- Independent Health Association
Enrollment: 61,341
Intermountain Health Care
- Select Health
Enrollment: 47,705
Leon Health
- Leon Health
Enrollment: 39,137
Lumeris
- Essence Healthcare
Enrollment: 55,027
MHH Healthcare
- MCS Classicare
Enrollment: 207,906
Missouri Healthcare Advisors
- NHC Advantage
Enrollment: 1,200
Network Health
- Network Health Medicare Advantage
Enrollment: 69,727
SNP Holdings
- West Virginia Senior Advantage
Enrollment: 852
Triton Health Systems
- VIVA Medicare
Enrollment: 54,211
UnitedHealth Group
- UnitedHealthcare of Wisconsin
Enrollment: 90,554
- KS Plan Administrators
Enrollment: 49,331
- Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co.
Enrollment: 49,125
- Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co.
Enrollment: 8,965
- Peoples Health
Enrollment: 97,472
- Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co.
Enrollment: 9,608
- Preferred Care Network
Enrollment: 39,879
- Sierra Health and Life Insurance Co.
Enrollment: 6,007
University of Wisconsin Hospitals and Clinics
- Quartz Medicare Advantage
Enrollment: 3,598
UPMC Health System
- UPMC Health Plan
Enrollment: 148,511
- UPMC Health Network
Enrollment: 18,950