CMS flags $112B+ in improper payments: 9 things to know

Advertisement

Improper payments across Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and the federal ACA exchange rose to an estimated $112.9 billion in fiscal 2026, up from about $96.1 billion a year earlier, according to estimates CMS released Nov. 16.

CMS defines an improper payment as one that doesn’t meet program requirements, including overpayments, underpayments and payments without enough documentation to show they were proper. Improper payments do not measure fraud, though some may involve fraud or abuse, others reflect administrative errors or missing documentation.

Nine things to know:

1. Traditional Medicare’s improper payment rate rose to 7.32% ($33.96 billion), up from 6.55% ($28.83 billion), in fiscal 2025. It marks the 10th consecutive year the rate has stayed below the 10% compliance threshold set by federal improper statutory requirements.

2. Medicaid carried the largest dollar total with its rate climbing to 7.08% ($46.84 billion) from 6.12% ($37.39 billion). About 79.41% of Medicaid’s improper payments stemmed from insufficient documentation. The estimate combines three review cycles of roughly 17 states each, from 2024, 2025 and 2026.

3. CHIP posted the steepest rate increase, rising 2.76 percentage points to 9.81%($2.26 billion) from 7.05% ($1.37 billion). Insufficient documentation accounted for about 55.93% of CHIP’s improper payments.

4. CMS attributed part of the Medicaid and CHIP increases to the end of COVID-19 public health emergency flexibilities. 

5. The Medicare Advantage rate fell to 5.68% from 6.09%, though dollars edged up to $23.86 billion from $23.67 billion. Most errors traced to Medicare Advantage organizations’ documentation failing to support the diagnosis data they submitted for payment.

6. Medicare Part D’s rate dipped to 3.85% ($5.16 billion) from 4% ($4.23 billion). Most Part D improper payments occurred because plan sponsors did not provide sufficient documentation to support prescription data used in payment decisions.

7. Advance premium tax credit payments on the federally facilitated exchange had a 0.84% improper payment rate ($830.37 million) for benefit year 2024, down from 0.89% ($657.46 million) for benefit year 2023. Automated errors, mostly duplicate payments tied to duplicate members and duplicate Social Security numbers, made up 59.24% of improper payments. Manual errors in reviewing consumer-submitted documents were the second-largest cause.

8. The traditional Medicare and Medicaid/CHIP figures are based on claims submitted from July 1, 2024, to June 30, 2025, before many of CMS’ current anti-fraud efforts took effect. Those include enrollment moratoria for high-risk provider types such as home health agencies and hospices, large-scale enrollment revocations and payment suspensions, expanded data analytics to flag high-risk Medicaid providers, and new state dashboards to catch Medicaid outliers. CMS expects those efforts to begin showing up in fiscal 2027 data, with larger effects in fiscal 2028.

9. CMS is also moving traditional Medicare claims processing onto a new platform, called ClaimsCore, which it said will support modern payment integrity controls and save millions of dollars, plus potential additional savings from improved program integrity.

Advertisement

Next Up in Financial

Advertisement