Springfield, Mass.-based Baystate Health has filed a lawsuit against Commonwealth Care Alliance, alleging the insurer owes nearly $14 million for care already provided, and will not renew its contract with the health plan effective Jan. 1, 2027.
The health system alleges CCA — which was acquired by CareSource last year — improperly recouped payments and violated the terms of its agreements for services already provided to patients. Baystate said it pursued legal action after efforts to resolve the dispute directly with the payer were unsuccessful.
“Baystate cannot continue to contract with an insurer that does not pay for the care we provide for its members in accordance with the terms of the agreement in place,” the system said in a Nov. 17 news release. “With nearly $14 million owed for care already delivered, these are the resources that support the services families in our communities depend on. As a safety-net healthcare provider, we have a responsibility to protect those resources and ensure we can continue to meet the healthcare needs of our region.”
In a statement provided Nov. 19 to Becker’s, a CCA spokesperson said the insurer has been working in good faith to renew its agreement with Baystate and hopes the health system will return to negotiations to avoid disruptions in patient care.
“Patients in Western Massachusetts should not unnecessarily be put in the middle of a financial dispute between two healthcare organizations they depend on,” the spokesperson said.
CCA said Baystate filed a contractual dispute in Suffolk County Superior Court in June and argued that the existing legal process should be used to resolve the disagreement rather than jeopardizing patients’ access to care.
“While we continue working toward a renewed contract, we have started notifying members of the potential network change in accordance with regulatory requirements, and are prepared to help them navigate their care options,” CCA said in a statement. “We remain ready to reach a reasonable agreement with Baystate Health that protects our members’ access to care while sustainably managing the public funds entrusted to us.”
Patients enrolled in CCA plans will retain in-network access to Baystate providers through Dec. 31, including providers joining the health system from Hartford, Conn.-based Trinity Health of New England. Baystate acquired Mercy Medical Center from TNOE, part of Livonia, Mich.-based Trinity Health, on Nov. 1.
Baystate said it will contact affected patients in the coming weeks with information about the network change and alternative coverage options.
