Humana, UnitedHealthcare dominate first half of Medicare Advantage annual enrollment

Advertisement

Humana and UnitedHealthcare accounted for nearly 6 in 10 Medicare Advantage applications in the first three weeks of the annual enrollment period, according to a new report from Medicare brokerage firm Spark Advisors.

The data was drawn from SunFire records and Spark platform applications covering Oct. 15 through Nov. 6.

Seven notes:

1. Humana holds 30% of Spark’s MA applications so far, with UnitedHealthcare close behind at 28%. Together the two carriers make up 58% of all applications submitted through the platform. Aetna follows at 15%, Devoted Health at 10%, and regional or other carriers at 9%. Elevance Health saw 5% and HCSC’s HealthSpring was 4%.

2. UnitedHealthcare’s applications are up 49% year over year, driven largely by new-to-agent clients, who make up 72% of its volume. Humana’s volume is down 11% from the same point last year, and it has the highest share of rewrites among national carriers at 22%, a reflection of the breadth of its plan cancellations. The insurer said earlier this year it would exit unprofitable MA markets, a move affecting about 600,000 members.

3. The share of MA and prescription drug plan beneficiaries facing a plan cancellation tripled to 9.2%, up from 2.6% in 2026. Nearly half of all beneficiaries (46.4%) face a higher maximum out-of-pocket limit, up from 25.1% a year ago, with a median increase of $600. The share facing a deductible increase fell slightly year-over-year (58.4% from 69.4%), but specialist copay increases held steady at about 29%. About 4.3 million Medicare beneficiaries will see their current MA plans or PDPs terminated on Dec. 31, compared to 2.9 million who faced forced disenrollment heading into 2026.

4. PPO enrollees are switching at a rate of 5.4%, the highest of any plan type, compared with 4.3% across all types. More than 90% of PPO enrollees also face a significant plan change this year, and only 40% of PPO switchers are choosing another PPO. Most are moving into HMOs (28% of switchers) and Giveback plans (22%).

5. C-SNPs saw their share of applications rise 30% year over year, the fastest growth of any plan type. The share of HMOs is up 12% and they now lead all applications at 27%, followed by Givebacks at 24%, D-SNPs at 21%, C-SNPs at 15%, and PPOs at 13%.

6. Humana captured 31% of all carrier switchers, and Devoted Health captured 18%, attracting six times more switchers than it lost. Meanwhile, regional and smaller carriers are losing three members for every one they gain. UnitedHealthcare’s beneficiary base is the most stable of any major carrier, with just 2.2% switching plans so far.

7. Aetna leads the Northeast with 43% of applications, while Humana leads the South at 33% and the West at 30%. In the Midwest, Humana and UnitedHealthcare are closely matched at 24% and 23%, respectively.

Advertisement

Next Up in Medicare Advantage

Advertisement