CVS Health and a former Express Scripts president have reached a settlement with Cigna over allegations that her departure violated a noncompete agreement.
Amy Bricker served as president of Express Scripts — Cigna’s pharmacy benefit manager — before resigning in January 2023 to become CVS’ executive vice president and chief product officer-consumer. She was set to begin her new position the following month, but Cigna sued to block her from taking the new job.
A mediation hearing was scheduled for May 30, but the parties reached a settlement before that date, according to a June 9 court filing. The terms of the agreement were not disclosed. CVS declined comment on the settlement. Cigna did not immediately return a message seeking comment.
Cigna alleged in the lawsuit that CVS’ hiring of Ms. Bricker puts its trade secrets at risk. Express Scripts outbid CVS Caremark in 2022 for a $35 billion PBM contract with Centene. Ms. Bricker helmed Express Scripts’ efforts, which led to a “high six-figure spot bonus,” according to the lawsuit.
CVS had argued that Ms. Bricker’s noncompete clause is unenforceable because it is overly broad and anti-competitive. The company also argued it does not apply to her new position because it will be dissimilar to her Cigna role.
In June 2023, a federal judge in St. Louis issued a preliminary injunction barring Ms. Bricker from providing services to CVS Pharmacy, CVS Health, any of its entities or any other business that is “engaged in a business similar to, or that competes with, the business of Cigna.” She was also barred from disclosing Cigna trade secrets or confidential information.
On Nov. 6, shortly after a quarterly earnings call where CVS publicly announced several senior leadership changes, Ms. Bricker was notified that the company was terminating her employment status.
At the Becker's 5th Annual Fall Payer Issues Roundtable, taking place November 2–3 in Chicago, payer executives and healthcare leaders will come together to discuss value-based care, regulatory changes, cost management strategies and innovations shaping the future of payer-provider collaboration. Apply for complimentary registration now.
